Ads: bug or feature

Nielsens latest alertbox is about ads and how they affect the visitors experience.
Read the quote below, and you’ll know how some people feel about pop-ups or similar forms of ads.

Another user entered the following comment on a major website’s feedback form: “You people should be ashamed of yourself! I did not ask to have 3 pop ups come across my screen when I visit you. I do not visit singles sites, and I don’t want to add 4 inches to my penis. As a matter of fact, I don’t use any of the services that pop up on my screen. I think it is disgusting that you money hungry bastards have infringed on my computer for your own selfish gain. From this moment on, I am boycotting you, and I am advising EVERYONE I know to do the same thing. Down with you and your pop up ads.”

People really don�t know what is going on with their computer. Most people have problems with regular applications like MS Office. These apps don�t behave like people want them to do. Sometimes it�s a bug, but more often it is the user who doesn�t know or see what might be causing the problem. Most users cannot distinguish between an error and a real feature. So according to the user the app behaves in a way that he or she cannot predict.
This drives me mad too. When a printer doesn�t do what he needs to do, when manuals are stating to press a non-existing button, things like that.
Ads are just the same. They drive you mad because your pc starts doing things that most people we cannot control.
I worked as an agent at a helpdesk and people really start to freak out when they get ads displayed for porn sites. At work, when their boss is looking over their shoulder :-)
For some I could say, you really shouldn�t have gone to that site. But the secretary that just wanted to book a cheap flight for their manager shouldn�t have gotten these pop-ups.
She didn�t do anything wrong and still this browser starts creating new screens. What happened? They start blaming the site, the application or even worse themselves.
While I was writing this I got a call from a colleague. Her keyboard-layout switched to querty layout, and she didn�t do anything. Off course she didn�t do anything. She just pressed alt-Shift too long. It is just a feature to switch keyboard layouts with a keyboard stroke. Not a very desirable feature, but not an error or a bug.

Ads are mostly perceived in the same way, as a feature build into the site or the application. Not a very desirable feature, but not an error or a bug.

Update

I didn’t want to mention IE, but this article hits the nail on the head:

Web developers should avoid the temptation to develop applications only for bug-ridden IE.

Read


The top 20 IT mistakes to avoid

The Most Hated Advertising Techniques

One Response to Ads: bug or feature

  1. Using pop-ups is a big no-no! You can’t do that not letting the user choose for it. I do think Google ads (AdSense) are a feature though, as it does provide some kind of service to your visitors. (I’ve written about this before, if you’re interested go to my site and search for “adsense”.)

Did you like it?
© 2003 - up to today